How to answer Google reviews: the good ones, the mixed ones and the unfair ones
Answering reviews is free and takes about six minutes a week, and it's the thing small businesses skip that costs them most. Here's what a good reply sounds like for each kind, so the button stops being the hard part.
Somebody deciding between two shops in Ridgeway reads the reviews, and then, more often than owners expect, reads what the owner said back. A wall of unanswered reviews looks like nobody's home. A short, calm reply under every one, including the sour ones, looks like a business somebody is still running. That impression is worth more than the reply's exact wording, so start with the habit and polish the wording later.
Want this handled instead of DIY'd? See pricing and get a fixed-price quote.
The one habit: a set time each week
Pick a slot, six minutes is usually enough, and open the Reviews tab in your Google Business Profile. Answer whatever's new. If there's a backlog from the last few years, answer the newest ten first and work backwards over a few weeks. Old replies still get read by anyone who scrolls, so a late answer beats none.
Answering the good ones
Keep it short and specific. Thank them by first name, mention the thing they mentioned, and stop. If they praised the Saturday lunch special, say so. A copy-pasted "Thanks for your feedback!" under forty reviews reads as exactly that.
One more rule: don't invite a return visit with a discount or a gift in exchange for reviews. Google doesn't allow paying or rewarding people for reviews, and it isn't worth risking a listing over.
Answering the mixed ones
Three or four stars with a complaint inside is the most useful review you'll get, because the reader can see how you handle a problem. Use this order:
- Thank them for saying it.
- Name the specific issue in a few plain words, so it's clear you read it.
- Say what you'll do, or what's already changed.
- Offer a phone number or email to sort it out offline.
Leave out the long defence. Whoever reads the exchange later will judge the tone before the facts.
Answering the unfair ones
Some reviews are wrong: the wrong business, a customer angry about something you don't control, a competitor's account, someone who never visited. Do two things and keep them separate.
First, reply anyway, once, calmly. State one fact if there is one, such as "we don't have a record of a visit on that date," and invite them to call. Skip sarcasm and skip accusations. The reply is written for the next reader, not for the reviewer.
Second, if the review breaks Google's rules, such as spam, fake reviews, off-topic content or a conflict of interest, flag it for removal from your profile. Google can take those down. A review that's merely harsh or that you think is unfair usually stays, which is why the calm reply matters.
| Kind of review | What to do | Tone | Flag for removal? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | Thank them by first name, mention the thing they mentioned, and stop | Short and specific | No |
| Mixed | Thank them, name the issue, say what you'll do, offer a phone number or email | Calm, no long defence | No |
| Unfair | Reply once, and state one fact if there is one | Calm, no sarcasm, no accusations | Only if it breaks Google's rules |
What never goes in a reply
Never confirm private details about a customer's visit, order or health. Never name the person who complained. And never write in anger; if you're annoyed, wait until tomorrow. The reply stays public for years.
Check that all your reviews are in one place
If you find yourself answering reviews on two different profiles for one shop, that's a sign of a duplicate listing splitting your reviews, and the merging duplicate listings guide covers the order that keeps them. If you'd like somebody to sit beside you for the first pass and show you what a good reply sounds like, that's included in every size of the Niagara SEO cleanup. Owners who want the bigger picture on how search work fits together can also see the SEO services page at thisismyurl.com, where my larger consulting work lives.
Email hello@niagaraseo.com with your business name and I'll take a look at how your listing reads right now.
Common questions
- How long should a reply to a review be?
- Two to four sentences is plenty. Thank them, mention the one thing they raised, and give a way to reach you if there's a problem to sort out.
- Should I answer negative reviews, or leave them alone?
- Answer them, calmly and once. Silence under a bad review reads as either not caring or not noticing, and the reply is written for the next person reading, not the one who complained.
- Can I have an unfair review removed?
- Only if it breaks Google's rules, such as spam, a fake review or off-topic content. Flag it from your profile. If it's just harsh, it will probably stay, and a steady reply is your best response.
Have a question about your own situation?
I reply within one business day.